Miss Julie that was published 9 years following Ibsen’ realist play A Doll’s Property, is one of naturalist activity which attempted to show that heredity, environment and sociable conditions instead of hard work form an individual’s fate. Strindberg looking at himself a naturalist and being an challenger of Ibsen’s ideas in A Doll’s Residence, wrote Miss Julie which has a naturalist negativity and declined the idea of women being self-employed and publishing themselves through the unfortunate circumstances they were in.
The physical worlds of the two plays are for some reason the same. In both cases the space can be an interior 1 and the scene is a single room completely described by the author. On the other hand Ibsen has used more stage sets on the stage in order to make this more realistic. Time plays an important function in the two plays. As the time goes by the peaceful happy feelings of the beginning of the play changes to a anxious one plus the protagonist approaches her doom. We can feel the same panic that the central characters think from transferring of the time.
Nevertheless , the cultural worlds of the two takes on are different. Strindberg has described the world of nobles and their maids where the variations between the interpersonal classes is very important and known continuously when Ibsen has chosen people who find themselves almost of the identical class. They all are working people who have reached their particular present circumstance with effort and the social classes seem to be not to make a difference here. In cases like this A Doll’s House, a realist perform, is more believable and like the everyday life of its audience.
Symbolism is a crucial feature in the naturalist movie theater and Strindberg has used this in several instances. The first symbol that individuals see inside the play is definitely the Count’s footwear. From the beginning with the play we all hear about the Count, the master of the home but he never shows up on the stage. When Miss Julie have gotten sex with Jean, and by doing so has dishonored very little, they are scared of the Count’s reaction and it is this fear that causes Miss Julie to commit suicide when her father comes back home. In all now the presence of his boots in some way symbolizes the Count’s himself although he is not present, but he has his authority.
The 2nd symbol is usually Miss Julie’s thoroughbred doggie which has consorting with the gatekeeper’s dog and Miss Julie herself is definitely angry in her mainly because she is convinced that her well-bred dog should lover with one of many same type. The dog may symbolize Miss Julie mainly because she that is considered to be via noble blood vessels and the mistress of the house partcipates in a marriage with Blue jean who is her servant. And her reaction to her doggie may symbolize her dad’s reaction to what she has completed. The desires for Jean and Julie that are symbols in nature give us an account of every character’s standpoint. Julie in her dreams is falling and climbing down which can imply that in her real life the girl with descending from her location. Jean on the other hand is going up and ascending which is a reaction to his personal desire to grow to a higher social class.
Another mark may be Miss Julie’s canary which is slain by Jean. The chicken is in crate and as it is the only factor Miss Julie wants to carry her it might symbolize very little and her identity. As she prefers to kill the bird instead of leaving that behind, the girl prefers to eliminate herself rather than staying in the same situation. The past symbol could be the fact that Jules commits suicide with Jean’s razor. Mainly because earlier inside the play Jean used that razor to shave, the razor may symbolize Jean’s strength and sexuality wonderful decision to not accompany her that resulted in her killing herself. Additionally, it may represent the male authority and dominance which has caused Miss Julie being so wretched to choose loss of life.
From the characteristics of naturalism and realism which can be viewed both in A Doll’s House and Miss Julie one can refer to the long explanation of the scenes that may not really be useful to the whole plan of the enjoy. For example the scene of Christine cooking with the food prep in Miss Julie plus the scene where Nora is playing with her children within a Doll’s Property may not be of any importance in the progress of the storyline but they are necessary to create a lifelike sense inside the play.
The two Julie and A Doll’s House’s Nora are represented as having identity challenges and they equally put the blame on their father and mother specially their particular fathers. But they are different in many ways. First of all, when Miss Julie starts discussing with Jean we come across that she is aware of her problems and that is why she functions strangely causing Jean to call her mad The girl clearly declares that she was brought up like a boy by her mother after which by her father coping with her childhood she is entirely confused with her true identification: “he helped bring me approximately despise my own sex, to get half a girl and half a man. That is to blame for what has happened? My father, my mother, My spouse and i myself? I actually myself? I havent received a do it yourself at all, I havent received a believed which I don’t get from my father, I havent gota enthusiasm which I don’t get from my own mother, plus the latest stage the equal rights of women and men that I received from my fiance, which I known as scoundrel pertaining to his pains. How in that case can it be my own, personal fault?
But Nora doesn’t appreciate her problem until the previous pages from the play once she observes the reaction of her partner to her magic formula. The second difference between those two characters can be their treatment of the problem. Miss Julie totally knowing her problem by no means takes a possibility to ditch her father also to find her true personality. Even when she actually is obliged to leave the house and flee as a result of so called shame she has taken to her father, she requests Jean to accompany her although the girl hates him. She can’t be independent by men, the lady finds it impossible to go away and live on her personal, she aren’t think and act separately and the girl even begs Jean to offer her orders. In this case she actually is the exact reverse of Nora. She is pleading for something that Nora is attempting to escape from.