The encounter between Chinese language and European cultures in the 17th hundred years highlighted the idea held by many people in Western european culture that they were better than the Oriental in matters of research, as well as culture and religion. I will work with two resources to support my own argument. Is Louis Votre Comte’s notification to Head of the family Philipeaux of France coming from 1697. Le Comte was obviously a French Jesuit missionary who traveled to Cina in order to propagate Christianity. His letter required observations and memoirs that covered how the Chinese approached scientific topics, and what their technological culture was just like.
The information in the notification gives us a clear take a look at what the France thought about the Chinese, that has been also a thought that occured by many in Europe. The other source that I will use is the Oriental World Map of 1602, which was of Matteo Ricci, Li Zhizao and Zhang Wentao, together with the translations by Ricci in the captions. These translations further more demonstrate the European thought that all they were superior to the Chinese language in many elements.
In my essay I will analyze the European thought that all they were superior to the China, specifically in the field of science of astronomy, astrology, medication, and location.
Before we have into the scientific subjects, and the culture which will defines all of them, we need a knowledge of how the Europeans recognized the Oriental. To do this we should examine Le Comte’s notice. This will help us understand the unsupported claims and argumentative tools that he uses to make the nation of Portugal appear understanding, while making the Oriental look conceited. The irony of this letter is the fact, by criticizing the Oriental for being pompous and rude, Le Comte is actually the main one being conceited and rude.
Le Comte is sightless to this subject because he does not believe that his country can be flawed. A good example of this is when Le Comte begins his letter by giving the Chinese credit for instilling “wit inside the people of Siam. Following making an attempt to seem like this individual respects the Chinese he goes on to offend them by saying that the Chinese believe that the “People of the East are “blind and that they imagine themselves being “the the majority of intelligent Region in the World. you What Le Comte meant by this is usually that the Chinese looked at the Europeans as unknowing and in the dark.
This view falls short of credibility, pertaining to though the China were a sophisticated culture plus some Chinese philosophers or scholars might have believed themselves superior to the Europeans, the Europeans definitely believed they were better than the Oriental. By saying that the China thought themselves superior this individual attempts to discredit all of them. This a sense of superiority can be described as moral superiority which stems from the belief that the French, Italians, and also other Europeans organised. The idea is they held themselves to higher moral standards like politeness.
The underlying element of the superiority complex that flowed through European nations was religion. Christianity was the key belief system and it shaped how a natural globe was considered. The way technology was carried out and considered was especially shaped simply by Christian beliefs. They supported one Goodness and that this kind of God controlled everything. In addition they believed that the way nature worked was because of God. This was as opposed to what the China thought. They believed in multiple beings and this there was strength called Chi that altered events inside the natural community.
This was viewed down upon by Euro scholars, especially by the Jesuits and they attempt to change the Chinese beliefs mainly because they identified them insufficient. This idea that the French were more advanced can be evident in Le Comte’s reflection about Chinese astronomy. According to Le Comte, “that never did People in the World addict themselves so frequently to it. He admits that that the Chinese language used this science to make an abundance of findings but the Chinese were vague within their notes and observations that they could not quite possibly maximize some great benefits of these findings.
This way of thinking about science as a way to profit a traditions is a very Western way of thinking, and Le Comte is utilizing it as a way to perspective his culture as superior because the Chinese do not make use of astronomy in the same manner as Europeans use it. An outright sort of the superiority that this Europeans experience is seen when ever Le Comte calls the Chinese massive tables not perfect, and that, although it took quite some time the China astronomers finally grasped “some skill in Our Astronomy. . He is producing the supposition that the Western european approach to astronomy is the a lot better than the Oriental approach.
The final comment this individual makes within this subject is how Chinese language successes to make calendars should be attributed to the Europeans. 5 By stating the Europeans should be credited with the Chinese’ calendar development; he the actual Chinese appear dependent on them as a income source. This meant reliance that Le Comte says the Chinese have for the Europeans the actual Europeans seem much more outstanding. The same notion of superiority is usually echoed simply by Le Comte in his comments on Chinese astrology, which we is going to take a look at in this paragraph.
Votre Comte is incredibly negative in his view on the Chinese astrologers. He looks at them since having a “knack of Lying and that they will be being fraudulent in declaring, for example , that good days intended for building and marriages rely “upon the Influence of the Heavens. The European explanation that he offers is the fact, rather than with respect to the heavens, these things depend on the “Wisdom and Discretion of Men. some This way of thinking is based off of Christianity. Their opinion system would not support the concept planetary movement, or celestial occurrences would influence things on Earth.
Within their minds Goodness was the resource that handled nature and the planets which were way out in space wasn’t able to possibly result events on earth. This proven fact that God regulates heaven and earth, while Matteo Ricci says inside the translations of his World Map, was the thought that the Jesuits had been trying to instill in the Chinese. The make an attempt to Christianize the Chinese could require the Chinese to abandon their very own current know-how system. This explains so why Le Comte is so harsh towards the Chinese by dialling them liars.
What Le Comte is intending to do, because they are extremely crucial of the Chinese’ astrologers, is usually discredit the Chinese and attack all their knowledge system by saying it is problematic. This case in point shows the way the Europeans thought that they were a lot more advanced culture, and it is the good example of what plans they would go to in order to instill their even more perfect religious beliefs on the China (My emphasis). Moving on towards the science of medicine we see similar European concept that the China were second-rate.
Le Comte attributes the possible lack of advancement in Chinese medicine for the desire with the Chinese to become more advanced in physics, organic philosophy and anatomy. You observe here, that even when the Europeans acknowledge the Oriental for being advanced in some areas, they still find a way to set a negative rotate on that acknowledgement. However, Chinese’ the majority of “famous research is degraded by Votre Comte. “Pulses, which made the Oriental famous around the world, was considered by China physicians since the “Foundation of all Remedies.
6 It is criticized by Le Comte because they were doing not work with “reasoning and arguing when ever practicing or perhaps learning this method. 6 This kind of “reasoning and arguing which the Europeans thought was essential for correct technological practice originated from the technological method which they believed would allow them to learn subject matter and also to conduct tests. Since the Chinese language did not employ this method, the Europeans immediately thought that the Chinese technique was not enough and that their way was better.
This led to the criticism of Chinese methods, and, just like astrology, the Europeans offender the Chinese of “pretending to know what they were carrying out because the Chinese relied about tradition and practice rather than methodology and testing. Votre Compte continues about how the Chinese “play the Prophet and how persons should not trust them since they use deception in order to get people to pay money for a remedy to their health problem. 7 He also illustrates a Chinese language medical practice which he says is “unmerciful.
The practice he is mentioning is the using a popular iron for the feet of folks that are bothered with Colick which is a ailment that causes “continual vomiting and “Gripes. The word that Le Compte uses to describe the practice is definitely “unmerciful and “violent. He sees the Chinese since barbaric which will would collection himself, as being a European, in addition to the Chinese. Once again, the Western belief that they can were more than the Oriental is echoed in this explanation of medical practices.
The Europeans presumed that the Chinese had a behavior of lying down and misleading in order to make a fast profit for just about any form of treatments. This is especially evident when Votre Compte remarks on the way which will people were allowed practice medicine without being qualified. He should go as far as to talk about that the Oriental who practice medicine without certification care more about the money that they receive off their patient, than if their sufferer dies. The idea that someone must be certified to practice medicine is extremely European.
Difficulties problem that Le Comte seems to have with this way of thinking that the Chinese have got is not that folks are dying, but that the China idea differs from the others from Europe’s. Europeans assumed themselves in all honesty and caring about applying medicine and medical practices to help people, which will made all of them superior to the Chinese. This relates back in the meaningful superiority that they can felt. Shifting from remedies let’s take a look at geography and map producing. During Matteo Ricci’s time in China he met Mr. Li Wo-ts’un, a studier of geography who made maps on the planet.
Ricci helped bring a map, that selection, to him and Wo-ts’un became “deeply interested in it. After seeing this map Wo-ts’un convinced himself that “the correspondence between puro circles plus the terrestrial examples of latitude and longitude was based on a great immutable law. To get an entire 12 months he made “painstaking calculations however according to Ricci, Wo-ts’un neglected the “narrow scope of his own map. Now, to be able to remedy this Wo-ts’un asked Ricci to create a much larger map, and Ricci agreed. Ricci’s description of why he agreed to associated with map is usually an attempt to belittle Wo-ts’un’s map producing skills.
As well, Ricci tries to seem good by saying that he will need help in making the brand new map in the old roadmaps of his “humble country. However , he is the opposite of humble if he finishes producing the new map. Ricci begins making a speech about how precisely God was your reason that he made this incredible map and that he looks “with expect and requirement to those who have, like himself (myself), will be sojourners with this earth. This is an attempt to provide credit to his Christian God. Ricci’s purpose of getting in Cina was to distributed Christianity, and so any opportunity to make his religion looks as if it had been the reason for anything important is taken.
By examining the need to spread their particular religion to the Chinese, we see that the European’s felt like the Chinese perception system was inadequate, and that they needed to rely on something else. This is actually the concrete example of the importance the fact that Europeans believed. Religion was your key motivator that manufactured Europeans feel superior to the Chinese. By examining the encounter which the European missionaries and China had in the 17th hundred years we see that the Europeans believed superior to the Chinese.
This feeling was evident once Ricci and Le Compte compared the sciences of astronomy, zodiac, medicine, and geography. The belief in Christianity that the Western european missionaries had was the first step toward the cause of this superior feeling. Comments: This kind of cultural come across was really interesting because it pointed out how the European’s were incredibly intent in pushing their particular religion for the Chinese. A very important factor I did not refer to was that the Chinese did not give in to the Jesuit missionaries because I really do not imagine it would put anything to the essay.
1) Matteo Ricci, Li Zhizao, and Zang Wentao. World Map of 1602. 2) Giles, Lionel. “Translations from the Chinese World Map of Daddy Ricci. In two files corresponding to two dates of distribution in, The Geographical Log, Vol. 52, No . six (Dec., 1918), pp. 367-385, and The Geographical Journal, Volume. 53, Number 1 (Jan., 1919), pp. 19-30 3) Le Comte, Louis. Memoirs and Observations Typographical, Physical, Mathematical, Mechanical, Natural, City, and Ecclesiastical, Made In a Late Journey Through the Empire of Chinese suppliers, and Printed In Several Letters¦ with Many Different Curious and Useful Comments.
London: Published for Benj. Tooke¦, and Sam. Buckley ¦, 1697. “”””””””””””””” [ 1 ]. Le Comte, Louis. p. 220 [ 2 ]. Le Comte, Louis g. 222 [ 3 ]. Le Comte, l. 222 [ some ]. Le Comte, s. 223 [ 5 ]. Giles, Lionel p. 370 [ 6th ]. Le Comte, Paillette p. 224 [ 7 ]. Le Comte, Louis g. 225 [ eight ]. Le Comte, John p. 227 [ 9 ]. Le Comte, Louis l. 231 [ 10 ]. Giles, Lionel l. 368 [ 14 ]. Giles, Lionel l. 369.
You may also be interested in this: cultural come across essay