A comparison among one flew over the cukoo essay

h Nest as well as the Bell JarWhat could a convicted rapist possibly have in common with a youthful aspiring feminine writer? These types of characters, portrayed by Ashton kutcher Kesey and Sylvia Plath respectively possess a lot more in accordance than one could think. Ken Keseys story One Travelled Over the Cuckoos Nest, and Sylvia Plaths autobiographical story The Bells Jar happen to be two significantly different tales. These two tales, however have striking commonalities in the concept that each of these conveys, a communication commenting for the poor manner in which mental health issues, or perceived mental disease is cared for by the medical community. Commonalities in the two novels is seen when evaluating the reasons that protagonist of each and every novel was committed as well as the treatment that was administered, specifically medicines given, and Electro-shock remedy treatments.

The Bell Jar is a saving of a length of confusion, mold, and revival in the existence of its protagonist. In the beginning of the book Esther Greenwood is portrayed as a quite successful scholar and fresh woman. She’s, in essence, the all-American girl. She grew up with fifteen many years of straight Since, attended an ivy-league womens college and spent her weekends in Yale. This kind of novel can be an autobiographical account of Sylvia Plaths breakdown like a young woman. Greenwood, just like Plath, was a young female who reached her vocation early and as a result suffered in creasing seclusion from her peers. It can be clear in the very first lines of the book that Greenwood has a handful of instabilities. As the story progresses the decline of Greenwoods health is evident. She basins into not only a mental illness, but a severe circumstance of depression. A case of depression that today could possibly be cured using a steady diet plan of Prozac was cured in a wholly different method. Greenwood was taken to a psychiatrist who also attempted to continue to treat her condition. Her meeting with the psychiatrist basically served to frustrate Greenwood further, driving her more deeply and more deeply into her depressed state. Greenwood could not even locate understanding or perhaps comfort in her psychiatrist.

Thus i told him again in the same uninteresting flat tone, only it was angrier on this occasion, because he appeared so sluggish to understand how I hadnt slept for 18 nights and exactly how I couldnt read or write or perhaps swallow well.

Greenwoods depression escalated and eventually your woman attempted to commit suicide yet failed. This is when Greenwood was initially officially institutionalized. Greenwood was thrown right into a ward pertaining to the psychologically ill. Her depression had been treated between schizophrenics and catatonics, individuals with disorders far more severe than her own.

An author creates what he / she knows. Tobey maguire Kesey, as a young person, volunteered for medical trials with the then simply new medicine LSD. His experiences with this drug that often mimics the symptoms of schizophrenia, as well as together with the medical community prompted Kesey to write the novel One Flew Above the Cuckoos Nest. The leading part, Patrick Randle McMurphy, inside the novel One particular Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest is a man that by no means should have recently been committed. The nurse, within a group therapy session explains exactly why McMurphy was committed, according to his data file.

Committed by the state through the Pendleton Plantation for modification. For diagnosis and possible treatment. Thirty-five years old. Under no circumstances married. Known Service Combination in Korea, for leading escape from a communist camp. A dishonorable launch, afterward, for insubordination. Accompanied by a history of street brawls and barroom fights and a series of busts for Drunkenness, Assault and Battery, Disturbing the Tranquility, repeated betting, and one particular arrest-for Afeitado.

He can a man with a long criminal record but simply no record of mental disease. The state no longer knew what to do with McMurphy, therefore they directed him apart and hoped for the best. McMurphy did not by any means benefit from the treatment he was presented, he was getting treated for any sickness that he basically did not have. At best McMurphy was simply a loud individual, at worst having been a man affected by Attention Deficit Disorder needing some Ritalin. McMurphy was by no means outrageous.

Although these kinds of stories will vary, and even though both Greenwood and McMurphy were committed in completely different ways intended for entirely different reasons, a similarity could possibly be drawn. Every character was misdiagnosed for their illness and therefore mistreated too. Neither Greenwood nor McMurphy truly suffered with a mental illness and thus neither of which should have been institutionalized.

One of the steps to Greenwoods recovery was treatment through medication. After Greenwoods first suicide make an effort she awoke in a mixed up and numb state.

Atmosphere breathed and played more than my face.

I experienced the shape of a room about me, a big room with open windows. A pillow molded itself under my head, and my body sailed, without pressure, between the sheets.

Greenwood identifies her astonished muddled; perplexed; bewildered; blank; confused state because she awakens in this passage. It is a condition with which she becomes knowledgeable about as the novel moves along. The numbness that Greedwood feels through the drugs she actually is given appears to shut her off from the earth. She looses whatever will certainly she nonetheless had remaining to fight her way out of her depression. Although Greenwood sooner or later did, with quite a bit of support, pull very little out of her depression, the prescription drugs seemed to perform no part in the process with her recovery.

In Keseys story it was like clockwork, following breakfast and before bed medications received to sufferers in the ward. Each individual reacted in different ways about being given prescription drugs. Some of the patients for the ward took the medicine without asking any questions or even considering it. Some required to know the actual were being offered before consuming the pills anything the nurse never told them. Several simply declined to take the medication altogether they were handled sternly. And several of the even more extreme instances took their very own medication , but believed the pills were truly tiny electronic-controlling devices. Although the medications that McMurphy was handed did not apparently have any negative effects on him, they were doing not apparently have virtually any positive types either. In the event that anything McMurphy began to act out more following he started within the medications, generally due to his surroundings.

Greenwood and McMurphy both responded differently for the medications that they can were given. Greenwood was numb and astonished muddled; perplexed; bewildered; blank; confused while McMurphy did not notice much of a alter at all. Again though there is also a parallel between the two reports: the medicines that each from the characters was prescribed did not help. Each characters being was modified by the recommended medications, and neither in the characters attained anything in the medications.

Probably the most disturbing a part of both Plaths novel and Greenwoods treatment is the Electro-shock therapy that was given. On her second visit to her psychiatrist Greenwood was taken up the surprise room on her behalf first treatment. No preceding warning was handed and the procedure was not described at all to Greenwood. I had tried to ask him the particular shock treatment would be like, Greenwood talks about to the target audience before her first program

but when I actually opened my mouth not any words arrived, my eyes just widened and stared on the smiling, familiar face that floated in front of me such as a plate packed with assurances.

Greenwoods first shock remedy session was your last straw, so to speak. The feeling was and so mortifyingly agonizing that possibly simply the thought of going back for starters more terrified Greenwood past belief. Greenwood felt captured, life was painful enough for her when it was, to add physical pain to the already tormented life is what led Greenwood to her initial suicide make an effort. She arranges an encounter with fatality like 1 arranges a doctors visit. Her attempt for suicide was a failed a single and Greenwood was soon enough thereafter institutionalized. The path to recovery started out here, with little help from her doctors, Greenwood began to reach out, first using a fellow inmate at the asylum she was placed in. It was her that Greenwood received further distress therapy. Even though were not since horrifying while the first one these people were still certainly not exactly restorative, and did not seem to help in her progress at all.

The shock treatments are probably the most horrifying and vivid parts of not only The Bell Jar, but likewise in One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest. In Keseys new shock remedies are used not so much as an actual treatment as it is a punishment. This can be a deterrent of bad patterns. McMurphy is usually sent for his initially shock treatment after this individual attacks one of many hospital family and friends. He would not attack with out reason. Above all else, the nurse wanted to call and make an example of McMurphy. She did not want additional patients next in his rebellious footsteps. The other patients already researched to McMurphy, much of the novel, in fact is devoted to demonstrating how McMurphy teaches other patients to be sane the place that the doctors are unable to, the last thing which the nurse wanted was to allow them to start imitating him as well. The distress treatment provides another goal as well, that quiets throughout the patient for some days. Since the narrator of the history describes this:

There was times when Identification wandered around in a daze for as long as two weeks after having a shock treatment, living in that foggy, disorderly blur the whole lot just like the ragged border of sleeping, that grey zone between light and dark, or perhaps between sleeping and waking or living and dying, where you find out youre certainly not unconscious any longer but never know but what day time it is or perhaps who you are, or perhaps what’s the utilization of coming back in any way for two weeks.

Like other treatment options though, the shock therapies did not impact McMurphy in quite the same way that they do other sufferers. Most sufferers only knowledge a few distress treatments before quickly modifying their habit. McMurphy rejected to change. He was sent intended for repeated treatments with no success. More severe procedures were taken by the health professional in McMurphys treatment after the failed surprise therapy lessons.

Greenwood and McMurphy responded to surprise therapy sessions in different ways. Despite their various reactions, the end result of the therapy was related for both characters the therapy failed. This utterly inappropriate method of treatment drove Greenwood with her first suicide attempt and it worsened McMurphys state. McMurphys made worse behavior because of the therapy is what eventually triggered his death.

Radically several, yet strikingly similar, these two novels notify different tales and yet apparently convey a identical message to the reader about the poor take care of the emotionally ill. Misdiagnosis as well as treatment options that just did not operate, such as medications and shock therapy, prevailed in equally novels. Right now ask yourself: What could a found guilty rapist and a young aiming female article writer possibly share?

Tweet