Ethical problems a newspapers columnist

Honest Dilemmas, Heart Attack, Retirement, Moral Decision Making

Research from Composition:

The pilot only has a month to go prior to he is eligible for retirement. Your doctor know this kind of and amazing things whether, underneath these unusual circumstances, the girl with justified in withholding the knowledge about the pilot’s condition.

Withholding the information would be determined by the severity of the pilot’s heart tumour. Considering the initial will be traveling by air an airplane that holds over two hundred human beings, a doctor would not be justified in withholding the patient’s condition. The doctor will need to instead survey the condition and make advice to the air travel regarding the ideal course of treatment. Since the pilot offers only monthly to retire, withholding the knowledge might be detrimental to the physician’s and pilot’s career.

The excellent decision would be to report the pilot’s condition to the flight, this would make sure that the airline is aware of the pilot’s condition and though some may allow him to continue flying, the airline could have taken the essential measures to ensure the pilot can be medically suit. If the doctor withholds these details, the initial might get a heart attack whilst flying, and this might cause fatality to him and the individuals on board the aircraft. This may result in investigations which might unearth the doctor knew with the pilot’s condition and would ruin the doctor’s career. The aircarrier would not be familiar with doctor’s honest dilemma, as the doctor’s decision might have led to various losses.

Though the doctor provides the free will to withhold this information, your doctor is required by their oath to see the aircarrier in order to stop any loss of lives brought on by the pilot’s health. Tollefsen (2012)

declares Augustine would have informed the airline in the pilot’s condition, but Aquinas would not possess. Aquinas reason behind not educating the air travel would be mainly because, this condition might lead to the pilot recently been fired, and since he simply has a month there is likelihood he will reduce his old age benefits.

References

Stepinova, Meters. (2011). Aquinas’ Solution of Aristotle’s Énurétique Man and Augustine’s Two Wills. [Article]. Fresh Blackfriars, 92(1039), 322-340. doi: 10. 1111/j. 1741-2005. 2009. 01328. back button

Tollefsen, C. (2012). Augustine, Aquinas, plus the Absolute Norm Against Laying. [Article]. American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly: Journal of the American

Tweet